FIG Marketing
  • FIG News
    • Events
    • Press
    • Community Relations
  • Product R + D
  • Marketing + Branding
  • Business Development
  • Industry Insights

FIG Marketing

  • FIG News
    • Events
    • Press
    • Community Relations
  • Product R + D
  • Marketing + Branding
  • Business Development
  • Industry Insights
Product R + D

Should I Replace My Client’s Variable Annuity with an FIA?

written by James LeMay March 25, 2021
Should I Replace My Client’s Variable Annuity with an FIA?

You’ve had your initial consultation with a new client and in the discovery process, you’ve learned they own a variable annuity (VA). As part of your review, you’ll evaluate the VA policy to ensure that it’s properly meeting the client’s objectives.

A suitable replacement can be an uphill battle, and an unsuitable replacement will be a flat-out waste of time and will frustrate your client. Having a useful resource and a process for evaluating how to proceed is invaluable.

A good FMO partner should be honest with you and set realistic expectationsโ€”just because one can argue that a VA replacement is suitable, there’s no guarantee that an insurance carrier will want the business.

Knowing ahead of time what you’re up against will help you determine where your efforts are best appropriated and will help you set proper expectations with your client.

The Variable Annuity Replacement Process

First and foremost, get the current, most recent statement. Without one, it’ll be all but impossible to evaluate the policy. From there, follow these steps:

1. Determine what the client’s current and future objectives are for the policy.

In many cases, the policy was appropriate when they purchased it but may no longer be the best fit. Do they need it for income? If so, when? Is there a spouse, and if so, is joint lifetime income required? (Most VAs are set up at issue for single or joint income and can’t be changed.)

Is the death benefit a concern or priority? (If the policy is set for single income and there’s a spouse, then there’s a good chance the death benefit is important.)

2. Have a Morningstar Report ran on the policy.

A Morningstar review will break down the fees and provide a clear definition of any living or death benefits. These are essential pieces to the policy puzzle.

3. Run comparisons.

If the client’s objectives have significantly changed, the choice to replace a policy can be obvious and pretty cut and dry. When the goals are the same, things get tricky, and a powerful case must be made for how the new policy will better meet these objectives.

For these cases, the numbers will play an important factor. The more supporting documentation, the better. Demonstrating a clear advantage to replacing will be required. A strong client letter will also likely be needed.

vector image of people putting together puzzle pieces

Possible Reasons to Replace Variable Annuities

Here are some of the most apparent reasons a VA may need replacing:
  1. High policy fees. (This is typically the first complaint we hear from our agents and policyholders.)
  2. The VA no longer meets their objectives. Here are some common examples:
    • The VA policy was for income guarantees no longer needed due to other investments’ strong performance.
    • The VA was purchased for accumulation, but now the client wishes to preserve the death benefit.
    • The policy was acquired for accumulation but now wish to generate lifetime income.
    • Purchased for single income but now wish to generate joint income.
  3. The client or agent is looking for principal protection.
  4. More income can be provided on a guaranteed basis.
However, there are some hurdles to overcome, too:
  1. Any surrender charges that may incur.
  2. The policy has been in force for less than two years.
  3. Same selling agent. If the agent recommending the replacement is the same agent that sold the existing policy, the new carrier will question the objective. Circumstances change, so the sale may still be suitable, but the new carrier will likely more closely scrutinize the replacement.
  4. High-income base or guaranteed income. Suppose the objective is income, and you see a substantially higher income value than the current market value. In that case, it’s improbable that a new policy will be able to provide equal or greater income guarantees.
  5. High death benefit guarantee.

Related: Infographic: 7 Annuity Myths (and the Truths Behind Them)

Variable Annuity Replacement Case Study

Who: Mrs. Jones, age 72

Reason for replacement: Change in Objective

vector image examining a case study on variable annuities

The basics:

  • Nine-year-old VA purchased in 2011
  • Account value = $170,445
  • Lifetime income base = $235,144
  • Current income guarantee if triggered = $11,757 per year
  • Death Benefit = $170,445
  • Surrender Value = $167,187

We were provided with a statement. We then ran a Morningstar report to discover the following fees:

  • M&E = 1.70%
  • Net Sub Account Fee Range = 0.31% – 1.54%
  • Living Benefit Fee = 0.95%
  • Total fee range = 2.96% – 4.19%

Related: How Annuities Can Address Client Issues

The Backstory

The client no longer needed income. Her primary concern was the death benefit. We identified a fixed indexed annuity that would better address her current objectives. The following narrative was submitted to the proposed carrier along with the most recent statement, product illustrations, the Morningstar report, and a letter from the client acknowledging the benefits she would be giving up by surrendering the existing variable annuity contract.

The Message to the Carrier

This email is in regard to Mrs. Jones, the use of the proposed (unnamed FIA) and it being funded by the replacement of an (unnamed variable annuity). The client Mrs. Jones has sufficient other assets and income and doesn’t need these particular qualified funds for income. The primary objective is to minimize fees, eliminate losses, and protect and grow the death benefit as much as possible.

Should the client need these funds to supplement her income, it would be ten or more years down the road. In that event, she may elect to take free withdrawals or turn on lifetime income depending on her health at that time and if the income need is determined to be permanent. Should the client’s health begin to fail and she cannot perform 2/6 ADLs, she may elect to take advantage of the 2/6 ADL enhanced income feature.

The death benefit of the existing VA is currently $170,445.

The surrender value is $167,187.

After applying the 10% bonus of $16,718 to the surrender value, the day one five-year payout death benefit of the (unnamed FIA) will be $183,905 and will grow at 250% of the indexed interest performance with zero fee drag. The existing (unnamed VA) has total fees in the range of 3.11% to 4.34%.

The (unnamed VA) policy doesn’t have a fixed account option and must average a gross annual return of 3.873% to 5.103% over the next ten years in order to match the day one five-year payout death benefit of the (unnamed FIA). It has no principal protection, so there are no guarantees that the client will not actually end up with a lower death benefit down the road than what they have today. The client lost $38,819 in the last year alone.

The policy was issued 40 days after the application was signed.

Final Thought on Variable Annuity Replacements

When it comes to VA replacements, leverage your resources, be thorough, follow a process, and set proper expectations. Even if the answer is “Hold onto this policy, we can’t do better at this time,” your clients will thank you.

Keep Reading: Annuities Help Protect Against Longevity Risk


financial independence group logo

The content within this article is for educational purposes only and does not represent legal, tax or investment advice. Customers should consult a legal or tax professional regarding their own situation. This article is not an offer to purchase, sell, replace, or exchange any financial product. Annuity products and any related guarantees, features and/or benefits are backed by the claims paying ability of an insurance company. Annuity policy applications are vetted through an underwriting process set forth by the issuing insurance company. Some applications may not be accepted based upon adverse underwriting results.

Should I Replace My Client’s Variable Annuity with an FIA? was last modified: March 26th, 2021 by James LeMay
Case studyvariable annuitiesvariable annuity replacements
0
LinkedIn Facebook Twitter

You may also like

8 Common Investment Mistakes to Avoid

April 8, 2021

It Was the Best of Times, It Was...

April 1, 2021

IUL vs. GUL: Which Makes the Most Sense?

March 18, 2021

Modified Endowment Contracts: Setting Up a Personal Pot...

March 10, 2021

A Look at IUL Fees, Costs, and Illustration...

March 5, 2021

Imagine the Future of Life Insurance Illustrations

February 23, 2021

David McKnight’s Tax-Free Income for Life Book Summary

February 4, 2021

Ways to Get Clients Thinking About Multi-Generational Wealth...

January 14, 2021

2020 Election: What a Biden Presidency May Mean...

December 11, 2020

Why Care Planning is Vital to a Financial...

November 30, 2020

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube

BLUEPRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Enter your email address below to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts.


Thank you for subscribing!

Suggested just for you

  • What are the Charges Deducted from Indexed Universal Life Policies? [Infographic]
  • Financial Services Website Design Tips & Fundamentals
  • The 4 R's of Managing a Successful Business
  • Tom Hegna: How Retirement Planning is Changing
  • Is the Boutique Business Model Just a Trend?
  • Top Client Concerns to Help Increase Engagement & Drive New Business
  • GUL vs. Protection IUL
  • Key Traits of Effective Financial Professionals

Tags

40th Anniversary advisor marketing Alphastar Capital Management annuities Annuity Annuity Awareness Month branding business consulting Business Development business management business tips Care Planning Case study client communication Client Relations client relationships compliance Digital marketing DOL financial advisors Financial Independence Group fintech Fixed indexed Annuities infographic Investment and securities IUL life insurance Life Insurance Awareness Month Long term care LTC LTC Awareness Month marketing tips office systems Press Release prospecting recruiting Retirement sales idea Sales tips social media surge Surge Business Consulting talent solutions Technology website

figmarketing

Financial Services Conglomerate Offering #Annuities, #LifeInsurance, #CarePlanning, #DisabilityInsurance, And Much More
โ€ข
๐Ÿ“ž (800) 527-1155
โ€ข

Financial Independence Group
Premium financing is a savvy tool that can make se Premium financing is a savvy tool that can make sense for a lot of investors. Essentially, it's a lending of funds to an individual to cover the cost of an insurance premium.

Listen in to our recent #RetirementInsideOut episode with our partners from #Schechter to hear more about premium financing and other advanced planning strategies.

Link in bio for full episode.
โ€ข
โ€ข
โ€ข
#FinancePodcast #FinanceTips #PremiumFinancing #LifeInsurance
๐Ÿšจ new #RetirementInsideOut episode! We had a g ๐Ÿšจ new #RetirementInsideOut episode!

We had a great conversation with our partners from #SchechterWealth on some pretty cool planning strategies. Tune in to hear their insights and expertise on:

โ€ข Advanced #InsurancePlanning
โ€ข Premium financing and who's right for it
โ€ข Unique solutions for business-owning clients
โ€ข ๐˜ˆ๐˜ฏ๐˜ฅ ๐˜ฎ๐˜ฐ๐˜ณ๐˜ฆ

Link in bio to listen!
We ๐™๐™ค๐™ฅ you and your family have a very #H We ๐™๐™ค๐™ฅ you and your family have a very #HappyEaster today! ๐Ÿฐ
If you haven't tuned into our #RetirementInsideOut If you haven't tuned into our #RetirementInsideOut episode with @davidcmcknight, make today the day. โœ…

We talk business strategy pivots, personal branding advice, how the #PowerOfZero is even more important now, and much more!

Link in bio for full episode ๐ŸŽ™๏ธ
Phil Puma, president of @pumahomes, joins us on #R Phil Puma, president of @pumahomes, joins us on #RetirementInsideOut today to talk #RealEstate! ๐Ÿก

Link in bio for full episode.
โ€ข
โ€ข
โ€ข
#Podcast #NewEpisode #FinanceTips #FinancialPlanning #HousingMarket #Mortgage
We hope your day is filled with as much joy as a l We hope your day is filled with as much joy as a leprechaun doing an Irish jig. Happy #StPatricksDay, y'all! ๐Ÿ€ ๐ŸŒˆ
Same insightful event. Same amazing location. Now Same insightful event. Same amazing location. Now with new dates.

๐—ฅ๐—ฒ๐—ด๐—ถ๐˜€๐˜๐—ฟ๐—ฎ๐˜๐—ถ๐—ผ๐—ป ๐—ถ๐˜€ ๐—ผ๐—ฝ๐—ฒ๐—ป for the FIG Sales Symposium on July 14-16 in Las Vegas, and we can't wait to host you! With keynote speakers like Michael Kitces, Trey Gowdy, and Kindra Hall, plus some fun entertainment each night, this year's #FIGSaleSymposium will be an event to remember.

To learn more about the event, keynote speakers, entertainment, and to secure your spot, head to FIGSymposium.com today.
Let love rule today and always. Happy #ValentinesD Let love rule today and always. Happy #ValentinesDay to you and yours! ๐Ÿ’˜
๐Ÿšจ New episode! ๐Ÿšจ Sheryl J. Moore, the chief ๐Ÿšจ New episode! ๐Ÿšจ

Sheryl J. Moore, the chief storyteller at Wink, Inc. and president and CEO of Moore Market Intelligence, joins us on #RetirementInsideOut today.

She's providing some fresh new outlooks on:
โ€ข How rate changes are affecting #FixedInsurance
โ€ข The regulation changes that'll affect the industry going forward
โ€ข Why #Annuities are becoming a hot-ticket product

๐ŸŽ™๏ธ Tune in wherever you go for podcasts or click the ๐Ÿ”— in our bio!
Have you heard our #RetirementInsideOut podcast wi Have you heard our #RetirementInsideOut podcast with @mkitces yet?

We tackle:
- Landing new clients
- Todayโ€™s fast-changing environment
- And a possible retirement dilemma?

Tune in now wherever you listen to #podcasts or click the link in our bio! ๐Ÿ”— 
โ€ข
โ€ข
โ€ข
#FinancialPlanning #FinancialProfessionals #FinancialPlanner #FinancialIndependence #Retirement #RetirementPlanning #RetirementGoals #NewPodcast #Podcast #Podcasts
Load More
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube

Financial Independence Group, Inc.ยฎ
1-800-527-1155

Our Products Are Strong, But Our Strength Is In Our People.ยฎ

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

ยฉ 2020 Financial Independence Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Back To Top
Subscribe to the FIGย Blueprint

Enter your email address below to receive content as soon as it comes out.

Thank you for subscribing!