FIG Marketing
  • FIG News
    • Events
    • Press
    • Community Relations
  • Product R + D
  • Marketing + Branding
  • Business Development
  • Industry Insights

FIG Marketing

  • FIG News
    • Events
    • Press
    • Community Relations
  • Product R + D
  • Marketing + Branding
  • Business Development
  • Industry Insights
Product R + D

Fixed Index-Linked Annuities Can Be a Safe Harbor

written by Bobby Samuelson January 6, 2022
Fixed Index-Linked Annuities Can Be a Safe Harbor

Ever since the advent of fixed indexed annuities (FIAs), there’s been speculation about whether or not the product category should be a security or a fixed insurance product.

Both sides of the argument have merit.

On one hand, FIA products don’t expose the client to any loss of principal and, therefore, don’t have any classically defined investment risk. As such, they should be classified exclusively as insurance products.

But, on the other hand, FIA products are complex financial instruments that provide exposure to equities through derivatives, a construct that would certainly require SEC registration without the guaranteed minimum values provided by the life insurer.

And where do the newer fixed index-linked annuities, or FILAs, fit? Are they fixed products or securities?

Related: The Emergence of the Fixed Index-Linked Annuity (FILA)

SEC Rule 151A

The debate over FIAs being a fixed- or securities-based product came to a head in mid-2008 when the SEC proposed Rule 151A, which removed indexed annuity contracts from the insurance exemption of the Securities Act of 1933 if “the amounts payable by the insurer under the contract are more likely than not to exceed the amounts guaranteed under the contract.”

The blowback from the life insurance industry was swift, strong, and spearheaded by a lawsuit filed just one month after Rule 151A was adopted.

By mid-2009, bills had been introduced in both the House and the Senate to undo Rule 151A and the District of Columbia US Court of Appeals subsequently ruled to vacate Rule 151A.

The Harkin Amendment

But the nail in the coffin of the SEC’s efforts to register FIAs (and now, FILAs) as securities products happened with the Harkin Amendment to the Dodd-Frank Act regarding Wall Street reform and consumer protections.

The Harkin Amendment instructed the SEC to “treat as exempt securities described under 3(a)(8) of the Securities Act of 1933 any insurance or endowment policy or annuity contract or option annuity contract…that satisfies standard nonforfeiture laws or similar requirements of the applicable State at the time of issue.”

This created a clear and bright line for life insurers to follow: as long as the product complied with fixed standard nonforfeiture laws, then the product is exempt from SEC registration.

Related: FILA vs. RILA: Where Do They Fit in a Portfolio?

FILA & Fixed Standard Nonforfeiture Law

As with any other FIA product, a FILA is fully compliant in both letter and spirit of the standard nonforfeiture law and passes both the retrospective and prospective tests.

As such, our view is that a FILA clearly qualifies for exemption from registration under the Harkin Amendment.

But even without the Harkin Amendment, we would argue that FILAs are no different in their ultimate risk profile than any other FIA product in terms of the potential for loss at the end of the crediting term.

What sets FILAs apart from other FIAs is the enhanced choice and flexibility within the long-dated crediting strategy to modify the risk and return profile within the confines of a 0% floor at the end of the crediting period.

That’s the unique, differentiated, and compelling story of a FILA.

Although FILAs can exhibit similar characteristics to RILAs, the core value proposition is the guaranteed principal protection that ensures that a FILA is fully and completely within the safe harbors of the Harkin Amendment and is exempt from registration as a security.

Keep Reading: A Deep Dive Into FILA Mechanics


Editor’s Note: This article is from our partners at LifeInnovators.com, and a similar PDF version can be downloaded for free here.

life innovators logo
financial independence group logo

Copyright Life Innovators LLC 2021

Fixed Index-Linked Annuities Can Be a Safe Harbor was last modified: January 6th, 2022 by Bobby Samuelson
FIAFILAfixed index-linked annuityFixed indexed Annuitiesfixed insurance
1
LinkedIn Facebook Twitter

You may also like

Solving for Aviation Risk & Premium Finance [Case...

April 28, 2022

7 Thoughts to Share With Those Anxious About...

January 20, 2022

F&G Trailsetter℠ & The Future of Life Insurance...

December 16, 2021

FILA vs. RILA: Where Do They Fit in...

December 9, 2021

What to Know About Hybrid Long-Term Care Annuity...

November 18, 2021

What is Fixed Index-Linked Annuity (FILA) and How...

October 28, 2021

The Rise of Insurtech: Arming Advisors with a...

October 11, 2021

A Deep Dive into FILA Mechanics

August 9, 2021

Finding the Right Annuity for Your Clients

July 29, 2021

Ways Life Insurance Can Soften the Blow from...

July 19, 2021

FIG Marketing ElevateU Charlotte - June 2022

quinci powered by simon side ad

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube

BLUEPRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Enter your email address below to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts.


Thank you for subscribing!

Suggested just for you

  • What are the Charges Deducted from Indexed Universal Life Policies? [Infographic]
  • 23 Crucial Years & 10 Birthdays That Impact Retirement Income
  • The 4 R's of Managing a Successful Business
  • A Look at IUL Fees, Costs, & Illustration Manipulation
  • The Emergence of the Fixed Index-Linked Annuity (FILA)
  • PRESS RELEASE: Barnabas Capital Announces Head of Structured Products
  • Client Segmentation Guide for Wealth Management Firms
  • 4 Steps to Naming a Financial Services Company

retirement inside out side ad

financial independence group GIFT initiative donor-advised fund side ad

Tags

advisor marketing annuities Annuity Annuity Awareness Month branding business consulting Business Development business management business tips Care Planning Case study client communication Client Relations client relationships compliance Digital marketing DOL financial advisors Financial Independence Group fintech fixed index-linked annuity Fixed indexed Annuities infographic Investment and securities IUL life insurance Life Insurance Awareness Month Long term care Long Term Care Insurance LTC LTC Awareness Month marketing strategies marketing tips Press Release prospecting recruiting Retirement sales idea Sales tips social media surge Surge Business Consulting talent solutions Technology website
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube

1-800-527-1155
Our Products Are Strong, But Our Strength Is In Our People.®

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Mobile App Privacy Statement

© 2022 Financial Independence Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved.


Back To Top
Subscribe to the FIG Blueprint

Enter your email address below to receive content as soon as it comes out.

Thank you for subscribing!